Skip to content
tavernatzanakis

tavernatzanakis

General For All

Primary Menu
  • General News
  • Art And Entertainment
  • Baby & Parenting
  • Education
  • Fashion
  • Home
  • About Us
    • Advertise Here
    • Contact Us
    • Privacy Policy
    • Sitemap
  • Home
  • A Case of Conflating Events with Systems? – Education Rickshaw
  • General

A Case of Conflating Events with Systems? – Education Rickshaw

By Sybil T. Mann 3 years ago

[ad_1]

A problem I’ve faced when debating the advantages/disadvantages of direct instruction and inquiry-based learning is that educators tend to define them in different ways. The confusion stems from how both inquiry-based learning and direct instruction can be seen as either 1) discrete instructional events or 2) whole systems/approaches to teaching.

It’s common to hear teachers and instructional coaches using “direct instruction” in the general sense to refer to a brief moment of demonstration or explaining. But direct instruction, explicit instruction, and similar terms, are also used to describe the repertoire of daily review, modeling, guided practice, checking for understanding, and independent practice (among other things) that characterize effective teaching. The first meaning is a single instructional event that all teachers do from time to time, and the second is a whole system describing all of the events that make up the gradual release of control from teacher to student.

I think we see the same thing with inquiry-based learning. While all “inquiry” teachers explain things to students (and thus, could legitimately say, “I use both inquiry and direct instruction”), the whole system meaning of inquiry-based learning, where students must determine the focus of an investigation (often based on a passion or an interest) and direct their own learning through various phases until a product or an action emerges, is completely at odds with the whole system meaning of direct instruction. While “direct instruction” teachers might end instructional sequences by having students apply their new understandings in increasingly less structured ways – a phase that I recently heard a teacher calling “inquiry time” – it is only after material has been fully explained, rehearsed, and practiced to mastery, and never before.

When I’ve argued that inquiry-based learning unfairly advantages students with higher levels of prior knowledge, leads to issues with student behavior, and is incompatible with how humans acquire and construct knowledge, I’m referring to the “whole system” definition of inquiry-based learning; The one in which novices are expected to learn by cycling through self-guided inquiry phases – much like a scientist or a dissertating PhD student – to generate a product of their choosing. But if we operationalize “inquiry” as an event in which students are compelled to think hard about or do something with the material, it’s clear that inquiry plays an important role in learning. A high-quality education should include plenty of opportunities for students to inquire into things, if inquiring means focused processing (Renkl, 2015) and generating questions about the material. I’m even okay when teachers assign hands-on activities – even ones that are *gasp* a little open-ended – and having students working in groups and completing projects, but only after students have acquired the enabling knowledge that will allow them to be productive and produce something of value. This isn’t a compromise position, but an approach that is consistent with the expertise reversal and guidance fading effects of cognitive load theory.

In short, I’m fine with inquiry during the unit. I just don’t think it’s good for our students when inquiry becomes the unit.

Reference

Renkl, A. (2015). Different roads lead to Rome: the case of principle-based cognitive skills. Learning: Research and Practice, 1(1), 79–90. https://doi.org/10.1080/23735082.2015.994255

Like this:

Like Loading…



[ad_2]

Source link

Tags: Amazon Business Credit Card, American Airlines Business Class, Att Business Login, Austin Business Journal, Best Bank For Small Business, Best Business Bank Accounts, Best Business Schools In Us, Best Business To Start, British Airways Business Class, Business Attire Men, Business Card Ideas, Business Casual Shoes For Women, Business Continuity Planning, Business Entity Search, Business Letter Template, Business Management Degree, Business Manager Facebook, Business Plan Outline, Business School Rankings, Colorado Business Search, Delaware Business Entity Search, Drop Shipping Business, Family Business Bet, Fox Business Live, Georgia Sos Business Search, Google Business Account, Harvest Small Business Finance, How To Build Business Credit, Is Saturday A Business Day, Is Sears Still In Business, Microsoft 365 Business, My Business Google, Name Generator Business, None Of Your Business, Ny Sos Business Search, Open A Business Bank Account, Pa Business Search, Plus Size Business Casual, Pnc Business Banking, Sos Business Search Ca, Sunbiz Business Search, Taking Care Of Business, The Business Of Being Born, Turbotax Home And Business 2020, Tx Sos Business Search, Venmo For Business, Verizon Business Plans, Virtual Address For Business, What Are Business Days, Women Business Casual

Continue Reading

Previous What are the national SDG 4 benchmarks?
Next Bloomberg adds five to its investigations team
June 2025
M T W T F S S
 1
2345678
9101112131415
16171819202122
23242526272829
30  
« Apr    

Archives

Categories

  • Art And Entertainment
  • automotive industry
  • Baby & Parenting
  • business insurance
  • Dating & Relationship
  • Dental Clinic
  • Education
  • Fashion & Beauty
  • Fitness Gym
  • Games
  • General
  • General News
  • Health
  • Home & Improvement
  • Technology Global

Recent Posts

  • How to Prevent Short Cycling and Prolong System Life
  • Reliable Backup Strategies for Business and Home Use
  • Maintenance Tips for Iron and Steel Industry Equipment
  • Stunning Alexandrite Necklace Designs: A Guide to Choosing the Perfect Piece
  • Treats for Dogs: Discover Online Options, Goat Treats, and Fish Treats

Fiverr

Fiverr Logo

Tags

Amazon Fba Business Atlanta Business Chronicle'S Boss Baby Back In Business Business Administration Degree Business Attire Women Business Card Design Business Cards Templates Business Casual Dress Business Casual Outfits Business Checking Account Business Credit Card Business For Sale Near Me Business Intelligence Platform Business Lawyer Near Me Business Loan Calculator Business Name Ideas Business Professional Women Business Spectrum Login California Business Entity Search Capital One Spark Business Carl Weber'S The Family Business Charlotte Business Journal Custom Business Cards Delaware Business Search Florida Business Search Fl Sos Business Search Harvard Business Publishing Insurance For Small Business Kelley School Of Business Maryland Business Express Maryland Business Search Moo Business Cards National Business Furniture New York Business Search Ohio Business Gateway Onedrive For Business Online Business Ideas Paramore Misery Business Risky Business Cast Small Business Insurance Spectrum Business Customer Service Tom Cruise Risky Business Us Small Business Administration Verizon Wireless Business Verizon Wireless Business Login
craftdive
wisatajawatimur
tavernatzanakis.com | Magazine 7 by AF themes.

WhatsApp us